My thoughts on Ichiro’s trade and a crazy day

Crazy day yesterday. Crazy for the Mariners, for their fans, for their ownership. And, yeah, for their media.

I was flying back to Seattle from Tampa when the trade of Ichiro to the Yankees went down. First I heard of it was when I turned on my cell phone after touching down at Sea-Tac. So instead of a travel day and night off, I had my wife drive me straight to the ballpark so I could help with our and coverage package and to witness one of the stranger nights in  team history.

Hectic as my day turned out, it paled in comparison to what many of my friends in the Japanese media face. The group of Japanese journalists who’ve been following Ichiro in Seattle for years — men and women who have made their homes in Seattle for a decade  — suddenly are looking at picking up and moving to New York to continue the pursuit.

This is the magnitude of Ichiro in Japan, which I saw even more so in our week-long visit to Tokyo at the start of this season. Think about it. For a dozen years now, there have been as many or more Japanese journalists covering Ichiro in Seattle and on road trips than American journalists covering the entire Mariners team.

And now that he has been traded, they have essentially been traded as well. Crazy.

As for the deal itself? I’ve had lots of people ask why the Mariners would trade their iconic player and Future Hall of Famer for a pair of Minor League pitchers. And the answer is simple. Probably not as simple as the one the Mariners are giving, which is that Ichiro asked to be traded, so they accomodated.

That is part of the answer, but not all of it. Because the move helps the Mariners as well. They didn’t just do Ichiro a favor. They helped themselves by removing the overhanging issue of what to do with a declining star whose ties to Japanese ownership created an awkward situation for manager Eric Wedge and GM Jack Zduriencik.

If the club had felt compelled to re-sign Ichiro to a large contract and continue playing him in right field every day, they would have been continuing down the same path of making decisions that are based on things besides baseball.

The Yankees don’t have that issue. Manager Joe Girardi doesn’t have to worry what anyone thinks if he bats Ichiro lower in the lineup, as he already did last night by putting him eighth in the order. GM Brian Cashman doesn’t have to worry about being forced to re-sign Ichiro at the end of this year. He just got him as a rental player to see if there is any spark left.

My assumption is this two-month trial window will determine if Ichiro returns to the Majors next year. He’s opened himself up to other markets now, no longer tied to a young Mariners franchise where he didn’t fit with the rebuilding process or a lineup that desperately needs more power production from the right field spot, more oomph from its highest-paid player and more leadership from its most-tenured veteran.

And for the Mariners, they now have the freedom to rebuild their roster and set their lineup without the Ichiro factor forcing their hand.

Wedge hinted at that “Ichiro factor” the other day when asked if he considered using Ichiro as a relief pitcher in the 14-inning game when Miguel Olivo was warming up in the bullpen after the Mariners were down to their last available pitcher.

“Yeah, that would go over real good if I did that,” he said with a chuckle. “Just put my neck in the guillotine right now. I can’t fix it if I’m not here, you know what I mean?”

Wedge faced the same issue in making out the daily lineup, where penciling Ichiro in every game was expected. And as this season played out and it made more sense to give younger players time in the final months, that was going to be an increasing problem.

Many Mariners managers have dealt with the Ichiro conundrum, but Wedge is the first who has had to deal with it during Ichiro’s declining production. That wasn’t going to get easier in the coming months — or years if Ichiro had signed an extension.

So that’s why this move makes sense for the Mariners. And it makes sense for Ichiro, who I thought had grown stale in his Seattle situation and didn’t seem very happy the past two years. Every player gets old. No athlete yet has beaten Father Time. And few handle it perfectly.

I’ve been told by Japanese writers that even talking about age as an issue with Ichiro was taboo. But there is reality here and he’s not the same player he once was. Maybe there’ll be a spark in New York. He does seem able to rise to the occasion at times, but those times have been fewer recently.

In his last game with the Mariners on Sunday in Tampa, he dropped down a horrible bunt — right back to the pitcher — that got Casper Wells easily thrown out at third after Wells had led off with a double. On the heels of two bad throws the previous two games — one when he missed the cutoff man on the game-winning run in the 14th inning for the Rays on Friday and another when he received his first error of the season after forcing a throw that went wide of third and let Tampa score its lone run in Saturday’s 2-1 win — it was another bad moment for Ichiro.

But then we saw something different. Clearly irked at himself for blowing the bunt, Ichiro stole second. Then he stole third. In essence, he put himself on third after wiping Wells out of that spot … and then he scored the initial run on a double by Jesus Montero.

It was the impactful Ichiro we haven’t seen much of for awhile, the guy who could change a game with his speed and smarts. That’s the guy the Yankees hope they landed for the next two months.

And it’s the guy Mariners fans should remember when they look back at Ichiro’s career in Seattle.


Thanks for the great article Greg! Great to see your perspective on this crazy (and surreal) event. I hope you get some good R&R after this.

Thanks for the insight on the effects of Ichiro in the Mariner organization. While Wedge seemed like he was obligated to keep Ichiro happy by playing him daily, the Yanks nipped the issue in the bud by making no guaranteed position, playing times or place in the order part of the written agreement. Ichiro seemed to have control over lower management in the M’s, by forcing them to play him daily, etc, etc. His lead-off roll came to an end this season, but his willingness to contribute in the 2nd or 3rd spot seemed weak, to say the least. It wasn’t so much that he didn’t fit anymore as he didn’t want to fit but demanded playing time as if he was a major key to the future. Having a player that is bigger than the team is at least part of the problem this year. The Bone may not be the most tactful ex-player, but he did know what he was seeing, didn’t like it and said as much in reference to the M’s resigning Ichiro. And from how I understand it, Ichiro only had to ask once to be traded. I do respect Ichiro’s baseball stats, but that is where it ends for me.

I have nothing bad to say about Ichiro however I must say that after reviewing the NY line-up, Seattle should trade Jack Z and keep the players. Most of NY’s talent are ex-Mariners. It even makes me suspicious that NY is paying Jack under the table. I may have to change my favorite team to the hated Yanks after being a solid Mariners fan since 1977. I’m not as upset about that as you might think, after all, most of the Yanks are former M’s.

Here’s a spin-off of Gibbard’s Ichiro Theme Song, written by a Mariner’s fan as a tribute to Ichiro~ Hope you enjoy!

One positive about losing Ichiro is that Seattle sports media can no longer make cheap easy copy by targeting him. … Trade your leading hitter and base stealer, team leader and defesive stalwart (Oh sorry, he’s now got one error)? Great!! But lucky for him. Oh! Not a leader you say? Well find me a better “leader by example” than Ichiro. Every one of the Mariner prospects bennefit by watching Ichiro prepare for games and for each new season. And what kind of superstar would have stayed as long as Ichiro – in a wasteland of scores of minor league teammates and non-producing free agents? … Now the Mariners only have two legitimate major leaguers to go with their AAA ‘prospects’. And one of the two (Vargas) is at risk of leaving for another 2 ‘prospects’. Mike Golic is probably right. Seattle has become a AAA team that provides players for other teams. … However, what a team it would be if ex-Mariners who now play elsewhere were to return. .. Or maybe just as the last guy said, players who are now Yankees. .. And while I’m on a ‘ranting’ roll. Why is it that all these prospects are failing to produce? Seems to me that is either a mistake by management in drafing or acquiring them; or a failure of field management and coaches to get them to perform to their potential. ….. On a more positive note, this group of young guys might just be poised to elevate their games next year. If so let’s hope that the team holds on to Vargas, so we start the 2012-13 season with two solid pitchers. And it would be nice for fans for the rest of THIS season to have those two major lewaguers to watch.

team that provides wik

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: